This excerpt from the brand new guide titled “” is printed with permission from Jonathan Howard, MD and Redhawk Publications.
By Jonathan Howard
On June 29, 2021, Dr. Harriet Corridor penned an essay on the web site Science Primarily based Medication titled “A New COVID-19 Fable?” through which she wrote:
A correspondent advised I ought to have identified that the pandemic was over months in the past. That’s clearly a fable. However the place did that concept come from?1
I knew the reply. Even earlier than the primary wave peaked, docs advised the worst was over and that measures to regulate the virus had been extra harmful than the virus itself. This message was repeated often all through the pandemic.
On March 17, 2020, Dr. Zubin Damania – a doctor, comic, and web persona often called ZDoggMD to his followers within the “ZPAC Supporter Tribe”2 – recorded a podcast titled “COVID-19: Is Our Treatment Worse Than the Illness?”3 He made 4 comparable podcasts with Dr. Monica Gandhi. In October 2020 they recorded “ Cease Residing in Worry of COVID”4 the place listeners heard Dr. Gandhi say that “you possibly can nonetheless see your family and friends whereas retaining your self secure, and also you’re not gonna die of this.” In February 2021 they recorded “The Finish of the Pandemic”5 the place listeners heard that “a UCSF infectious illness physician is satisfied this pandemic is ending, and before you suppose.” Drs. Gandhi and Damania shared a stomach chuckle then, mocking variants by saying “variants shmariants.” The Delta and Omicron variants would each arrive a number of months later, and Dr. Gandhi would admit to regretting this remark.6
This didn’t cease her from making a virtually equivalent podcast in Could 2022 titled “Residing with COVID,”7 which declared “we now have all the mandatory instruments to finish the COVID ‘emergency part’. Right here’s how (and why) we are able to stay with this coronavirus.” They recorded one other podcast in December 2022 titled “A Higher Pandemic Playbook”, the place Dr. Gandhi once more made her case for “COVID optimism” and spoke of “how little extreme illness there’s.”8 She mentioned that, as a result of excessive charges of immunity, “since March of 2022 we’ve seen little or no extreme illness within the hospital.” In actuality, 160,000 Individuals died of COVID from March to December 2022, and COVID was the third main reason for demise for the third yr in a row.9
Early within the pandemic Dr. Gandhi believed that if COVID killed over 100 Individuals every day, residents would band collectively and forestall this in any respect prices.10 Sadly, she was flawed about this too. Regardless of her near-perfect report of poor predictions – which included her predicting she would cease making predictions on The Mehdi Hasan Present6 – San Mateo County celebrated their re-opening with Dr. Monica Gandhi Day on June 15, 2021. Though 596,374 Individuals had died of COVID by then, Dr. Gandhi reduce a ribbon of masks as a part of the celebration. The Delta variant arrived instantly after, and 500,000 extra Individuals would die of COVID earlier than the top of 2022.
Many instances, docs’ sarcastic admonition to “wait two extra weeks” turned out to be extraordinarily dependable indicators of when circumstances would spike once more. In a since-deleted tweet, Dr. Ramin Farzaneh-Far mentioned this in November 2020, proper earlier than the deadliest wave of the pandemic. In June 2021, Dr. Anish Koka mocked those that had been involved in regards to the Delta variant, saying “we’ll know in 2 weeks,”11 together with a watch roll emoji. A month later, the headlines would learn “Pediatric Hospitals in U.S. in Peril as Delta Hits Kids.”12 Economist Dr. Andreas Backhaus quipped in regards to the Nice Barrington Declaration and one among its authors, Dr. Sunetra Gupta, by saying:
I considered writing a paper that estimates how lengthy it takes for a rustic or area to undergo from a extreme COVID19 outbreak after the GBD crew mentioned that it had already reached herd immunity. One may name this new relationship the “Gupta predictor”.13
Dr. Gupta was not the one creator of the GBD to repeatedly declare the virus has been tamed. Dr. Jay Bhattacharya mentioned COVID had been “defanged” on: April 14, 202114; Could 3, 202115; July 21, 202116; July 28, 202117; and January 6, 2022.18
I too was overly optimistic, writing on July 25, 2021:
We’ll virtually definitely by no means have months in a row the place over 1,000 Individuals die every day. Once more with the caveat {that a} nasty variant might change every little thing, I’m assured the worst is over for the US as a complete, at the least for vaccinated folks.19
Sadly, these new variants appeared, and the worst had but to reach in a lot of the nation.
Notably, practically each physician who declared the pandemic over continues to debate COVID always, undermining their admonitions that everybody else ought to deal with COVID like some other illness.
Dr. Jonathan Howard is an Affiliate Professor of Neurology and Psychiatry at NYU Langone Well being and the Chief of Neurology at Bellevue Hospital. For added info, go to .
“We Need Them Contaminated” is accessible via writer Redhawk Publications at
1. Corridor, H. (2021, June 29). A brand new COVID-19 fable? Science-Primarily based Medication. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/a-new-COVID-19-myth/
2. Zubin Damania. (2022, November 19). In Wikipedia. https:// en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Zubin_Damania&oldid=1122695599
3. Damania, Z. (Host). (2020, March 17). COVID-19: is our treatment worse than the illness? [Video podcast episode]. In ZDoggMD: Barely funnier than placebo. https://zdoggmd.com/paul-offit-COVID/
4. Damania, Z. (Host). (2020, October 11). cease residing in concern of COVID [Video podcast episode]. In ZDoggMD: Barely funnier than placebo. https://zdoggmd.com/monica-gandhi-2/
5. Damania, Z. (Host). (2021, February 22). The top of the epidemic [Video podcast episode]. In ZDoggMD: Barely funnier than placebo. https://zdoggmd.com/monica-gandhi-3/
6. Gandhi, M. (2022, February 4). Mehdi Hasan questions physician on COVID predictions [Video interview]. In The Mehdi Hasan Present. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VaSTb5kNT4s
7. Damania, Z. (Host). (2022, Could 15). Residing with COVID [Video podcast episode]. In ZDoggMD: Barely funnier than placebo. https://zdoggmd.com/living-with-COVID/
8. Damania, Z. [ZDoggMD]. (2022, December 11). A greater pandemic playbook [Video podcast]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6j0u2n_kubw
9. Ortaliza, J., Amin, Ok., & Cox, C. (2022, November 10). COVID-19 main reason for demise rating. Kaiser Household Basis. https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-COVID-19/issue-brief/COVID-19-leading-cause-ofdeath-ranking/
10. Fisher, M. (2021, September 4). The COVID endgame: Is the pandemic over already? Or are there years to go? The WashingtonPost. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/COVID-how-will-itend/2021/09/04/44bdd69a-fed7-11eb-a664-4f6de3e17ff0_story.html
11. Koka, A. [@anish_koka]. (2021, June 30). Is it doable Howard & co. Are accurately predicting Armageddon until the youngsters aren’t compelled to be vaxxed ? Possibly.. (we’ll know [Tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/anish_koka/standing/1410346527290179590
12. Goodman, B. (2021, August 17). Pediatric hospitals in U.S. in peril as Delta hits youngsters. WebMD. https://www.webmd.com/COVID/information/20210817/pediatric-hospitals-us-in-peril-delta-hits-children
13. Backhaus, A. [@AndreasShrugged]. (2021, April 9). I considered writing a paper that estimates how lengthy it takes for a rustic or area to undergo from [Tweet; thumbnail link to tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/AndreasShrugged/standing/1380653456227196928
14. Damania, Z. (Host). (2021, April 14). Centered safety for COVID [Video podcast episode]. In ZDoggMD: Barely funnier than placebo. https://zdoggmd.com/jay-bhattacharya-2/
15. Bhattacharya, J. (2021, Could 3). The Ingraham Angle [Video interview transcript]. Fox Information. https://www.foxnews.com/transcript/ingrahamleft-doesnt-want-to-debate-they-want-to-dominate
16. Hill, Z. Ok. (2021, July 21). Stanford doc Jay Bhattacharya calls vaccine mandates ‘unethical,’ says sufferers can select. Newsweek. https://www.newsweek.com/stanford-doc-jay-bhattacharya-calls-vaccine-mandatesunethical-says-patients-can-choose-1611938
17. Polumbo, B. (2021, July 28). Regardless of ‘Delta’ alarmism, US COVID deaths are at lowest stage since March 2020, Harvard and Stanford
Professors clarify. Basis for Financial Schooling. https://charge.org/articles/despite-delta-alarmism-us-COVID-deaths-are-at-lowest-levelsince-march-2020-harvard-and-stanford-professors-explain/
18. Arnold, J. (2022, January 6). Pandemic of out of date speaking factors. Household Analysis Council. https://www.frc.org/updatearticle/20220106/pandemic-points
19. Howard, J. (2021, July 25). “We’ll have herd immunity by April”: Reflections on a failed prediction. Science-Primarily based Medication. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/well-have-herd-immunity-by-april-reflectionson-a-failed-prediction/
Associated